Archive | July, 2010

Falun Gong scares me

27 Jul

1. Falun Gong has a global network of newspaper (which is ad-free and intensively distributed), propaganda and events. Yet they claim they do not charge or receive donations from followers. It has been widely speculated that our good o Uncle Sam is behind them, these claims of course has never been proved.

2. While claiming to be a peaceful organization and a spiritual movement, 90% of their propaganda has something to do with “anti-CCP / religious freedom / human rights”. The actual content of the movement is quite weak and generally ignored by the general public.

3. Ah, yes. Speaking of the content of the movement, I have seen a lot of wild claims, for example, that Master Li can walk through walls and stuffs? And nuclear reactors buried in middle east, aliens experimenting on human beings and end of world is coming? Give me a break. These crap aren’t even close to Taoism.

4. What kind of “spiritual movement” would have so much verbal violence in their teachings and writings, and what kind of “peaceful religion” would constantly send their followers to danger confronting the CCP? In history’s sense? Usually a cult.

5. They talked about CCP brainwashing of people who oppose them. To be honest, CCP propaganda is very ineffective, and mainstream Chinese get tired and bored with them. However, most Chinese I know of, especially those from Hong Kong, who basically hates CCP to the guts, also hate Falun Gong. I wonder why.

6. Speaking of brainwashing, Falun Gong disregards all comments against them as CCP propaganda. Anything that happens against their favour is blamed at the CCP. The incident at Flushing* and the incident at Tiananmen** is quickly blamed as a CCP conspiracy. Grumpy mobs attacking Falun Gong missionaries? CCP agents. To me, setting up a symbol of hatred to divert all doubts is a very common way to brainwashing. The same tactics happen over and over and over again with all religions.

7. If you search online about Falun Gong, there are overwhelming endorsement of the sect. Most comments are emotionally fuelled, and if you look closely, most are from Falun Gong sources. When you finally find some neutral sources critizing Falun Gong, they are usually bombarded by Falun Gong people, citing uncredible references from their Falun Gong newspapers.

8. For an organization largely disliked by Chinese people in general, the manpower and financial resources, as well as their domination and manipulation of the media disturbing.

9. I URGE EVERYONE TO LOOK ON BOTH SIDES OF THE ISSUE AND THINK CLEARLY ABOUT THIS RELIGION.

DISCLAIMER:

1. I’m not affected by CCP propaganda. Not even close. I’m a Hong Kong born Chinese living Australia for 5 years now. In fact, I’ve received overwhelming ANTI-CCP propaganda throughout my life.

2. Believe it or not, I’m not a CCP agent!

3. I grow up rather neutral, if not dislike, CCP. But that doesn’t mean I’m supporting the Falun Gong cause, with the slightest sense.

4. I do not endorse, support or accept the brutality of torture and abuse of any human beings. But in the case of Falun Gong, I am extremely doubtful of how much their claims in CCP abuse is acutally true.

5. And even if it is the case, while I will condemn the CCP on that matter – I will never suport Falun Gong.

*Flushing incident: A group of Chinese are running a charity event for the Xichun earthquake, and some group of people, identified as Falun Gong missionaries, stop people from donating. They claim that the earthquake is in fact bad karma, and states that the donations will go to CCP pockets. Not quite surprisingly, they got beaten up. FLG quickly denounced the attackers / Falun Gong missionaries as CCP spies.

**Tiananmen incident: 5 persons, identified as Falun Gong sect members, torched themselves at Tiananmen Square. FLG again, denied involvement and blamed a CCP conspiracy.

text from: http://www.facts.org.cn/puop/201006/t112559.htm

A book of Zhuan Falun brings harm to three generations

27 Jul

76-year-old aunty Liu Qinghua from Donghe Town, Wangcang County, Sichuan Province, used to have a happy family with three generations under one roof. She had three sons and one daughter. They were all bright and capable, and also married and settled down. Her youngest son Chen Gang was especially smart and sensible as a child. He was a top-notch student at school and the apple of his parents’ eye. After high school, he passed into a university successfully and got a good job in a bank of his homeland after graduation. And then he married with a town girl in the county, and later had a lovely daughter. Here, for aunty Liu Qinghua, she enjoyed a well-off life with the filial descendants gathering around, which was the envy of many people in this mountain area of northern Sichuan. The area is still a top poverty-stricken county so far. However, all these have changed due to the book Zhuan Falun brought by the son Chen Gang.

Chen Gang was brainwashed thoroughly by Falun Gong “theories” after coming into contact with Falun Gong during the professional training in Chengdu in November, 1998. He looked like a strange man and told everyone he met that Falun Gong was miraculous. He said most people’s knowledge of the universe in the past was wrong and many conclusions from modern science would be overturned by Falun Gong. And mankind would enter a new era. Only by following the Mater’s principles of “truthfulness, compassion and tolerance”, you would not get ill; if you were ill, you need not medication and injections; it also helped to avoid disasters, “go to a higher level”, “open celestial eyes” and “return to paradise” to be a God again, which were all fabulous.

Chen Gang was learned and courteous, and had seen the world in the eyes of neighbors, so many villagers joined Falun Gong when Chen Gang introduced it repeatedly and personally demonstrated practicing movement to them. At the same time, he persuaded his elderly parents, elder brother, sister-in-law and 20-year-old niece to practice Falun Gong, too. Most people didn’t feel its magic said by Li Hongzhi when practicing. Because the Master asked them not to take medicines and injections, some sick even got worse, but Chen Gang said it was eliminating “karma” and normal response to practice, and the practicing worked.

His father Chen Wanlin, suffering from senile tracheitis, was weak with age and was a chronic invalid. He got from bad to worse in health due to drug withdraw after practicing. His cough and expectoration were more serious; he felt suffocated and out of breath when walking. It was difficult for him to practice standing up, so Chen Gang asked him to sit for practicing. Later when he even couldn’t sit, Chen Gang told him to lie in bed listening to Li Hongzhi’s records teaching the Fa. And so, with the hope that Falun Gong practicing would bring miracle and good results, Chen Wanlin “eliminated karma” distressfully for nine months and finally died in tears in November, 1999.

Chen Gang’ wife Zhang Yan was disgusted with the husband’s not engaging in honest work and not caring about the family due to obsessing with Falun Gong. She tried her best to influence the husband by her patience and tender feelings hoping that the husband wouldn’t indulge in illusory world of Falun Gong, but her husband told her not to disturb “Dafa”, and said that anyone who disturbed “Dafa” was “devil” and would be punished definitely by the “Master”. For this reason, there were numerous fierce quarrels between the couple. Once the wife scolded Li Hongzhi, Chen Gang slapped her severely. Being driven beyond the limits of forbearance, the wife Zhang Yan divorced him in a pet, and then lived alone with her daughter arduously.

After the family broken, the wife treated her daughter as the only hope and gave constant care trying to raise her up. But Chen Gang also wanted to make the daughter be a “good person” following the principles of “truthfulness, compassion and tolerance”. So behind the ex-wife’s back, he often instilled the benefit of Falun Gong into his daughter whenever he saw her. He said Falun Gong was a great, high-level cultivation way in the world; those who practiced Falun Gong were “good persons” and were capable. He constantly called the daughter to the place he lived and the home of his “fellow practitioners” to watch the CD about Fa teaching and practicing; he also provided many books and materials for the daughter to see. The pure thought of the little girl was confused thoroughly by her father. Her mental state became bad gradually, and her personality was unsociable and eccentric. She was subject to changing moods and sometimes her eyes glazed over. Both at home and school, she looked different from the peers in words and behaviors. When Zhang Yan found that her daughter’s mental state and behaviors were abnormal, she was very anxious and sought medical help in all directions. Then the girl was diagnosed with serious mental disease, so that she had to stop the school work. Until now, the daughter still needs the mother’s help in daily life.

The husband died, the daughter-in-law left the home and the granddaughter got insane, when aunty Liu Qinghua mentioned these sore spots, she burst into tears and regretted deeply not stopping the son’s practicing Falun Gong originally.

text from: http://www.facts.org.cn/Data/02/201006/t112405.htm

Falun Gong is nothing more than Chinese yoga based on pseudoscience

27 Jul

From what I have read or been told about falun gong it’s really nothing more than Chinese yoga for people whose reality is based on pseudoscience. I know it involves physical postures accompanied by mediation which will supposedly promote mental/spiritual well being. I read an article in a magazine once with the “leader” stating by mastering falun gong you can obtain such metaphysical abilities as levitation and other supernatural powers. In my eyes, falun gong is as ridiculous as any other type or brand of a spiritual salvation that is defined by one living person (on an upside, at least their “leader” isn’t fictitious). Master Li, the “leader”, is the only person who can define the ways of F.G. therefore the ideology immediately causes me to burst into laughter and look at F.G. as nothing more than another man (Li) who is probably semi-intellectual who uses shills to control the minds of the mentally weak and needy. To me, the idea that a carbon based life form is to be looked at as a bringer of salvation is hilarious, pathetic and simultaneously horrifying in the fact that there are about 2 million people in the world that prescribe to the theory of falun gong.

 It’s a shame our species has bred beings that believe one of their own kind could be their bringer of salvation and are so mentally weak and distorted that they are sucked into a thin, as in lacking of content and containing no scientific relevance, vision of salvation in hopes of obtaining “supernatural” powers for no more than time and a likely weekly fee. I think the first step in demystifying any method that promises to bring salvation is if biological survival tickets (money) fit into the equation. I would imagine that a being that brings salvation would not be of biological content therefore would have an absent need for our (note the first word after the parenthesis) biological survival tickets.

text from: http://www.facts.org.cn/puop/201006/t112279.htm

Shen Yun in the eyes of a London retired teacher

21 Jul

Strangely enough, I’d forgotten all about this discussion, but when someone was offering leaflets outside my Chinese class I was definitely up for seeing the show. I write for a website called Dimsum. There’s no pay, but I can get to see the shows for free. I was allocated two seats in the front stalls at the RFH yesterday, a real treat for me and my husband. I was a bit surprised by an American MC, and to learn it was a New York based troupe, but fair enough. A bit glittery and slick, but more or less based on Chinese traditional stuff, and the orchestra and dancers were superb. The emphasis was on Buddhist and Daoist beliefs about the afterlife.

Things turned sinister towards the end of the first half. A dance drama showed Chinese police beating up a couple of women imprisoned for religious beliefs. Then there was a song, supposedly about a Chinese woman thinking of her folks at New Year and reminding them ‘Dafa hao’ -‘Da fa’ would be good. Suddenly it clicked – Dafa is the name of Falun Gong call their divine being. By chance I’d also rewatched the DVD, ‘Out of the Death Trap’, about people in a Chinese village dying because a strange new cult didn’t hold with medical intervention.

By the end of the interval there were six empty seats around me and a growing unease in the audience. Another dance drama was even worse, with a young child flung across the stage (all done in dance) and some people defending her and her mother against Chinese police.

This morning I was in a quandary. The show was slick, and entertaining, no doubt about it. But how to recommend to a Chinese readership a show that attacked their government? By this time I’d read in the programme that the ‘most of the performers practised the principles of Falun Gong’. There had been no indication of this at all in the pre-show notices. I decided to ring the RFH.

It seems my query was was one of many, including some from representatives from the Chinese Embassy. It’s a shame if the Chinese government thinks such a prestigious body as the RFH is sanctioning criticism at such a sensitive time, not to mention the audience which was predominantly Chinese. It isn’t as if it were a discussion forum with both side giving their views. I wondered if the RFH had been aware in advance of the content.

My point is that it should have been billed as ‘The Falun Gong Show’ and everybody would know where they stood. I felt suckered into going along with it. How I would have felt if I’d been Chinese and paid £55 for the seat, thinking I was going to see just traditional songs and dances? I imagine I’d be very angry.

When I lived in China I regularly attended Christian church services and visited Buddhist and Taoist temples. In fact, I was surprised at the level of religious tolerance.

I’ve decided not to write a review, but if anyone wants to read about a genuine Chinese/UK collaboration show with no covert message, there’s my review of the Five Circles Arts Festival on the review forum.

text from: http://www.facts.org.cn/puop/201006/t112223.htm

Why I don’t like Falun Gong

21 Jul

I’m just posting this on here because this is the same response I have to every pro-Falun Gong person who messages me. I hope this post will serve as a reference so that I don’t have to keep typing out the same message to the people who fill up my inbox.

I find Falun Gong problematic for a variety of reasons, but let me say I have nothing against Qigong. Qigong exercises are much older than Falun Gong and Li Hongzhi — he appropriated ancient Taoist and Buddhist exercises and added his own teachings. My problem is not the actual exercise. These are the problems I have with Falun Gong:

1. Deception.

In New York City there is a Chinese theater group called the Shen Yun Performing Arts Center. Every year, they put on a Chinese New Year show and claim to represent all of Chinese culture. I paid over $70 to see this show with my family only to find out that it was all anti-China, pro-Falun Gong propaganda. There was no mention that this was a Falun Gong show in neither advertisements (in all forms of media) nor the show itself. I am infuriated at this subversive tactic to rope people in to see something (at a cost, no less!) that claims to be a universal Chinese cultural show and then be something else (a platform for Falun Gong). I find this incredibly deceptive. How am I supposed to give credibility to an organization that cheats people?

Similarly, there are also New Tang Dynasty Television and Epoch Times newspaper. Again, both sources never reveal that they are funded by pro-Falun Gong organizations. Neither openly say where their funding comes from, then spout anti-Chinese news under the guise of “normal,” unbiased, and unaffiliated news sources.

Many Falun Gong practioners have urged me to “discover the facts” and “find the truth.” How can I? I find it morally repugnant to disguise a company (and worse, a news agency) as an unbiased and honest place, take people’s money (in the case of Shen Yun), then spout very clearly biased propaganda.

2. Co-opting Chinese Folk Religion for Political Purposes

Mr. Li takes ideas from Buddhism and Taoism to create his own teachings of Zhen Shan Ren and alters them. That’s fine, but then he has the nerve to turn around and insult his original sources by calling them fraudulent and incorrect. He steals their ideas then puts his altered versions on a pedestal, claiming that his ideas are the ultimate truth. As one with a Taoist background, that does not sit well with me.

Another aspect of this is that many Falun Gong practitioners do not believe in Chinese Folk Religion, Taoism, Buddhism, etc. In fact, a portion of them look down on these religions as mere superstition. Everyone is entitled to their own beliefs, but the issue comes when places like Shen Yu co-opt my folk beliefs to extol Mr. Li.
Again, Shen Yu does not reveal itself to be pro-Falun Gong, ropes neutral Chinese people in, then uses venerated deities like Kuan Yin and Tin Hau to spout pro-Falun Gong “truths.” At the last New Year Gala I went to, Kuan Yin was put on the stage and sang “Falun Dafa is the best.” I am a practitioner of Chinese Folk Religion, and I found this to be incredibly disrespectful. Using religious icons on unsuspecting believers is problematic for me.

3. The Piggy-Backing of Evangelical Christians

This alone makes me want to stay away from Falun Gong. Evangelical Christians love to take up the Falun Gong cause. It would be callous of me to say that they couldn’t care less about Falun Gong, but I think it wouldn’t be too far from the truth.

Evangelical Christians want to piggy back onto Falun Gong’s cause so they can break China’s resolve in keeping religion out of China. That way, when China’s barriers crumble, they can preach away at us poor ignorant devil-worshipping heathen Chinese. I see the Falun Gong organ harvesting television exposees airing only on the evangelical stations. The ads I see warning people about China’s alleged organ harvesting are also funded in part by evangelical organizations.

I do not want Evangelism in China for a multitude of reasons. The first and foremost is that the consequence of aggressive missions is the erasure of traditional Chinese culture. That thought is horrifying to me, and I refuse to go near anything the missionaries touch, which includes Falun Gong.

I apologize if that doesn’t make sense to anyone, but my opinions on this will not change. No amount of argument will refute the fact that I paid $70 for a Chinese cultural show that did not reveal it was a platform for Falun Gong…and so on and so forth.

If you really must, you can message me but only if you actually address my points. Don’t talk to me about freedom of religion or anything else because my problem isn’t with the teachings but with the methods of dissemination of information.

text from: http://www.facts.org.cn/puop/201006/t112125.htm

Played for fools, by “Shen Yun”

21 Jul

You’ve really got to hand it to the folks behind “Shen Yun,” the unconscionable piece of religious propaganda that appeared Thursday night in Shea’s Performing Arts Center.
 
Through an overwhelming promotional campaign that featured smiling attendants stationed at kiosks in local malls, they duped thousands of people into paying outrageous sums of money to watch a half-baked advertisement for Falun Gong (also known as Falun Dafa), a spiritual sect whose adherents have been brutally persecuted by China’s government.
 
Bravo, “Shen Yun.” You pulled one over on us.
 
Marketed as a survey of 5,000 years of Chinese culture through classical and folk dances from the country, “Shen Yun” turns out to be little more than a church pageant. Were it advertised as such, some of its flaws could be forgiven. Since it was not, it deserves to be held to account for the deception its creators have wrought.
 
The show contains several examples of bald proselytizing, including scenes in which followers of Falun Gong are brutally assaulted and —I kid you not, bro —repeatedly Tased. It also features performances of Falun Dafa songs, including one with the catchy title of “Nothing Can Block the Divine Path,”which implores listeners to follow the Falun Dafa way. There is no attempt at subtlety in the numbers, which are tossed in amid innocuous dances that give glimpses into various Chinese narratives and traditions as if they were just another story to be told. In fact, these numbers are the only reason the show exists.
 
I hesitate to delve too deeply into the artistic merits of such an unconscionable misuse of the ancient art of Chinese dance, but in the interest of fairness I will offer this: Imagine what it might be like to watch a synchronized swimming team perform in front of a gigantic Windows 95 screen-saver. That should give you a pretty good idea of where “Shen Yun”ranks on the artistic merit scale. The costume-heavy spectacle is more of a fashion show than a serious exhibition of the intricacies of Chinese dance, which is unsurprising given the company’s interest in dressing up its religious message in dazzling clothes.
 
Walking out of the theater —though I’d come knowing what to expect, as the company has amassed a reputation for its disingenuous marketing machine —I couldn’t help recalling a scene from “A Christmas Story.”In that scene, Ralphie, after saving up and waiting months to receive his secret “Little Orphan Annie” decoder ring, discovered when it finally arrived that it existed simply as an advertisement for Ovaltine. “Shen Yun,” to the great disappointment of those it promised otherwise, is really just another crummy commercial.

text from: http://www.facts.org.cn/Reports/World/201006/t112056.htm

Falun Gong: A new cult emerges

13 Jul

The rapid development in China of the religious cult known as Falun Gong is the most remarkable example of the growing popularity in recent years of millenarian beliefs.

The cult itself claims to have gained a following of 100 million people, most of them in China, since it was launched seven years ago. This figure, representing about one in twelve of the country’s population, is certainly exaggerated.

But the demonstration on 25 April by thousands of cult members in the most politically sensitive area of the capital clearly showed that it is highly organised and can mobilise supporters from a wide area. Some of the protesters were from the countryside and from other northern Chinese cities.

Cult members strongly object to the use of the words, “cult,” “religion” or “millenarian” to describe their beliefs. But this may well be a defensive measure in a country where such terms alarm the government.

The only officially approved religions are Taoism, Buddhism, Christianity, Confucianism and Islam, and the government exercises strict control over these faiths. Any other religious activity is condemned as superstition.

One reason why Falun Gong has succeeded in growing so fast without provoking a major crackdown by the government may be that the movement appeared to be little more than a variation on the traditional Chinese meditation system known as Qi Gong.

Many urban Chinese, both officials and ordinary citizens, practice Qi Gong as a way of keeping mentally and physically fit.

When the founder of Falun Gong, Li Hongzhi, emerged to expound his beliefs in 1992, he presented himself as a leading Qi Gong expert.
‘Superstition and false science’

But “Master Li” – as he is known to his followers – believed that people needed more than Qi Gong in its commonly practiced form to ensure their spiritual well-being.

In his book, Zhuan Falun, and in a series of lectures around the country and abroad, he described the importance of cultivating what he called one’s “Inner Nature” by upholding the three principles of Truth, Benevolence and Forbearance.

By doing so, the practitioner could move to a higher level of what he saw as a multi-layered cosmos. He explained that Buddha and Jesus, as well as himself, were beings from higher levels who had come to help humankind from the destruction it could face as a result of rampant evil.
Master Li’s book became the bible of the new sect. Practitioners read the work over and over again. In 1996, the government banned the work as superstition and false science. But copies produced in Hong Kong are widely circulated in China.

Leading intellectuals
The government may have resisted taking any further action against the cult because many of its followers are leading intellectuals, as well as some Communist Party members and officials. Falun Gong groups have mushroomed on university campuses as well as abroad among highly educated ethnic Chinese.

Some official newspapers have published articles attacking one of the central beliefs of followers, namely that true devotees are immune to illness and have no need to visit doctors.

But the demonstration in Beijing could well eventually result in a sterner response. The protest, albeit peaceful, quiet and orderly, must have been an embarrassment to the government given that it was held despite heightened security in the capital in advance of the 10th anniversary in June of the crushing of the 1989 Tiananmen Square protests.

text from: http://www.facts.org.cn/Reports/World/201006/t111976.htm

Feedback from Falun Gong

13 Jul

Some interesting responses were posted regarding recent articles about Falun Gong at CultNews.The fiery deaths and mutilations of Falun Gong protesters that set themselves on fire didn’t seem to raise any troubling questions to those still committed to Li Hongzhi and his “evil cult.”

Somehow the horrific spectacle in Tianamen Square was an indictment of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).

According to some Falun Gong devotees it was all a conspiracy and the CCP faked it.

However, that response directly contradicts a statement made by one of the survivors Chen Guo.

“We decided burning ourselves was the best way,” said Chen, who lost both hands. “It was totally due to our own will. We were not forced by anyone” she told the European news service Reuters.

“We wanted to strengthen the force of Falun Gong,” Chen explained while lying in a hospital bed in her hometown of Kaifeng.

Chen Guo now in her early twenties has a face that is a mass of skin grafts. She has neither a nose nor ears.

Nevertheless Hongzhi’s followers seem to believe whatever they are told through their own propaganda.

“The police in Tianamen Square, that day…had cameras readied to take videos of the incident.”

It was all part of a conspiracy concocted by the CCP.

One devotee said, “the girl and her mother was reported to have NEVER practice Falun Gong.”

But Wang Jindong, the man that masterminded the self-immolations told Reuters, “As to whether I am a practitioner or not, it’s not for other people to say.”

Wang’s face is badly scarred and his fingers blackened from the fire that claimed two lives.

Falun Gong has distributed CDs that claim to unravel the CCP conspiracy.

Here is an interesting comment.

“I’m not sure why you repeatedly refer to Falun Gong as a cult. According to Margaret Singer [there are] Six Conditions for thought reform” says another citing each in an attempt to disprove anyone that might label the group “cult-like.” “Please do more unbiased research to find out the facts,” concludes this comment.

But this Falun Gong devotee must not have bothered to read the article just below the one he or she was commenting about.

That article “Why all the fuss about Falun Gong?” quoted Margaret Singer.

She said, “If you want a good description of a cult, all you have to do is read what they say they are,” Margaret Singer told the San Francisco Chronicle at a Seattle conference in 2000 explaining her expert opinion about the group.

Those remarks drew some harsh feedback.

“Regarding your quote from Margaret Singer, well, let me just say that this whole experience has made me lose any respect for people who claim to be cult experts,” said another one of Hongzhi’s angry disciples.

Chen agreed with Singer. “I think Falun Gong has developed into a cult with anti-human and anti-society characteristics,” she explained.

“I hope those who still believe in this cult can be awakened and throw it away,” she told Reuters. “I don’t want to see another victim like me,” She told Reuters.

Wang concluded, “I feel humiliated because of my stupidity and fanatical ideas.”

But rather than examine and carefully consider those “fanatical ideas” Falun Gong goes on blaming everyone else, especially the CCP.

“We are dealing with this CCP and its mass of slanderous propaganda that has been exported globally.”

Hongzhi and his followers are quite adept at slinging their own propaganda, which has been effectively transmitted globally, with the help of Western journalists.

It seems that many Westerners are willing to believe almost anything about the CCP, rather than consider Hongzhi’s influence over his followers and its consequences.

The endless attacks against the CCP by Falun Gong devotees don’t change Hongzhi’s racist rant, or his homophobic statements. And that response won’t put Cheng Guo back together; her life has been shattered forever and it will never be the same again.

Why can’t Falun Gong followers consider these things?

“They actually say ‘Don’t Think.’ Just recite the master’s teaching,” observed Margaret Singer.

 text from: http://www.facts.org.cn/Views/201006/t111747.htm

Falun Gong: what’s behind the movements?

13 Jul

The political leadership of China is not the only group alarmed by the spread of Falun Gong, a term used to describe both a set of slow, graceful exercises and the banned Chinese spiritual movement that practices them.

Teachers of qigong, a 5,000-year-old Eastern healing art that includes tai chi, acupuncture and other practices that have become popular in the United States, cannot understand the growing appeal of the exercises.

“I don’t see how the Falun Gong exercises could work” to promote health, says Renxu Wang, a qigong master and retired Western-trained surgeon now living in Massachusetts. “Qigong strengthens the body. Falun Gong strengthens the soul for salvation . . . [by] adopting energy from different dimensions in the universe.”

Perhaps we should start by defining some terms. Falun Gong is the exercise component of Falun Dafa, a political and spiritual movement that has been banned by the Chinese government at least partly because authorities are concerned that its spread could destabilize the government. Officially, Chinese leaders call Falun Gong a dangerous cult.

Falun Dafa’s premise is that through a set of five exercises a practitioner cultivates an intelligent, golden-colored entity called the falun, which resides in one’s gut (but in a different dimension) and spins continuously, absorbing energy from parallel universes, thereby making the body invincible to disease. Falun Gong’s founder, Li Hongzhi, who lives in exile somewhere in Queens, N.Y., maintains that David Copperfield has some serious falun that allows him to walk through walls and perform magic.

While the vivid Falun Dafa imagery suggests a relationship to ancient forms of Eastern mysticism, the exercises were developed by Li in China in 1992. Which is to say, these exercises are no more ancient than step aerobics. Still, Falun Gong is beginning to attract people who have less interest in Chinese politics than in practicing the exercises.

At least a dozen indoor study groups meet in the Washington area, and there are many outdoor practice sites, including the Mall, Catholic University and the campus of the National Institutes of Health (NIH). The movement has reached into the suburbs, with practice groups massing at Montgomery Blair High School in Silver Spring and the Julius West Middle School in Rockville.

Yet seekers of the falun may not realize that the exercises are very different from other forms of qigong, which have been honed over centuries of practice.

“There are many differences between Falun Gong and qigong,” says Wang. First, there’s qi (pronouned “chee”), loosely defined as vital energy, the core concept of qigong. Through controlled breathing, practitioners of qigong direct vital energy within the body to locations that need it the most. In Falun Gong there is no breath work. Energy comes drifting in from forces that exist in different dimensions of the universe.

Qigong movements are precise, in order to maximize the flow of qi. Falun Gong practitioners worry less about the precision of their movements, Wang says, and indeed many practitioners render the poses very differently.

Further, qigong is practiced in many different forms to address many different ailments and goals; Falun Gong is a single set of exercises billed as a cure-all practice.

While the American medical establishment has not weighed in on Falun Gong, it is slowly warming to the more popular qigong practices known as “internal qigong”: tai chi, acupuncture and meditation.

“Qigong can elicit the relaxation response,” says Herbert Benson, an associate professor at Harvard Medical School and president of the Mind/Body Medical Institute in Boston. “Saying the rosary will do the same.” Benson says that qigong-induced relaxation can slow one’s metabolism, lower the heart rate and enhance resistance to disease.

Since 1990 the NIH has funded several small studies on the effects of qigong exercises for sufferers of neurological disorders, arthritis and other ailments. One study found that people over 70 years old gained more strength and cut their risk of accidental falls by nearly half after practicing tai chi. Larger studies are in the works.

Some practitioners make expansive claims about Falun Gong. In addition to providing the claimed link to universal energy fields and superhuman powers, they say, the exercises can cure everything from cancer to lifelong allergies.

The sitting pose, the “way of strengthening supernormal power” exercise, is similar to qigong meditation exercises that have been shown to lower blood pressure. The standing poses mainly stretch the upper body, similar to qigong poses that have been shown to improve circulation. The Falun Gong “penetrating the two cosmic extremes” exercise is quite invigorating. With this exercise, one’s arms move slowly up and down like pistons.

The “Buddha showing the thousand hands” exercise is most reminiscent of tai chi, with arms stretched from side to side, like a hunter pulling back on a bow. The “falun standing stance” exercise can build strength in the arms and shoulders, for the arms stay suspended for several minutes above the head. Finally, the “falun heavenly circulation” exercise involves running one’s hands up and down the entire body a few inches from its surface.

Falun Gong practitioners admit the moves are watered-down versions of qigong exercises, but that doesn’t matter to them. The exercises are not meant to be strenuous; rather, they cultivate universal energy.

“If you do it from your heart, you will benefit,” says Hailian Zhang, 34, who leads weekly group exercises on the Mall. By “heart,” Zhang means “xinxing,” a code of morality one must observe if the exercises are to have any benefit. Adhering to xinxing is yet another aspect that separates Falun Gong from qigong.

The stories of satisfied practitioners play out like late-night television testimonials. A retired white-collar worker from Beijing practicing on the Mall several weeks ago spoke of how Falun Gong had cured his skin allergies and chronic diarrhea, even though he doesn’t believe much in rotating, multidimensional faluns. A Chinese woman in her fifties spoke of how Falun Gong helped her regenerate bone that had been removed in surgery. A self-described Christian said Falun Gong has helped control his diabetes.

“You just do the exercises, and one day you wake up and realize you don’t have a particular [health problem] anymore,” says Keith Ware, a Washingtonian in his forties who practices and teaches Falun Gong at home and on weekend mornings on the Mall, often with his wife.

The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine at NIH and the qigong expert on the White House Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medicine Policy declined to comment on Falun Gong exercises. However, many health experts and some qigong teachers remain open to the idea that Falun Gong can provide some health benefits by reducing stress and boosting relaxation.

Yet some, as you can imagine, question the whole business of energy fields.

“There’s nothing wrong with graceful exercise as a relaxation technique,” says Stephen Barrett, a retired psychiatrist and editor of the Web site Quackwatch. “These practices can be mentally dangerous, though, when they instill false beliefs. False beliefs lead to bad decisions.” He cites the possibility that a belief in the absolute power of Falun Gong could lead sick people to refuse standard medical treatments.

Movements like Falun Gong enter into the realm of quackery, Barrett says, when they consistently make health claims that cannot be verified scientifically. This includes healing by touch, raising the paralyzed, curing cancer at far higher success rates than conventional medicines, sending vibes across the sea to heal at a distance or living for several hundred years — all claims that have been made for Falun Gong.

“Some movement is better than no movement,” Barrett said. “Socializing can have health benefits, too. People can do these things in a variety of ways.”

text from: http://www.facts.org.cn/Reports/World/201005/t111549.htm

My brief experience with the Falun Gong

8 Jul

Also known as Falun Dafa, Falun Gong has sparked world-wide controversy and heated debate. Is it a cult? A Buddhist religion? Or a qigong community with religious undertones? The verdict is still out.

Founder and leader of the organization Li Hongzhi claims to have studied under more than twenty Buddhist and Taoist masters. He also makes claims to divinity and possessing supernatural powers, besides promising that his disciples will also become godlike in power and ability.

These beliefs and religious undertones have resulted in harsh suppression of the group by the Chinese Communist government, which in turn has sparked to outrage and protest by many human rights groups.

Initially, Falun Gong was promoted as a government-recognized legitimate qigong (a.k.a. chi kung) organization. That quickly changed with the growing community’s membership and unofficial religious leanings.

Because qigong has a history of being associated with Taoism or Buddhism, (see History of Qigong), the Chinese government has allowed certain freedoms with these religions. However, it has also made it abundantly clear that qigong and other meditation practices are taught strictly for health and martial arts purposes.

With the emergence of the controversial teachings of Falun Dafa in the 1990s and the organization’s unofficial claim to practicing qigong for religious purposes, China has been less tolerant of such groups than ever before.

While I have no objection to any purported religious beliefs in connection with qigong, I am leery of what appears to be recruitment to cult-like practices.

My personal experience with the Falun Gong was very brief, beginning when the Falun Gong was first lauded as a very legitimate qigong organization in China. I had attended one of its meetings in the hopes of meeting like-minded people interested in furthering their experience in qigong practice.

After only a few minutes of meditation, without any special techniques in breathing and concentration that I could see, the entire room of fifty or so people began to jump up and down, shake various parts of their body, spasm or moan in trance-like states … almost everyone except the “teacher,” myself, and a few others.

Did I miss something here? In all my twenty odd years of training I had never seen any student – beginner or experienced practitioner – react so spontaneously at the direct suggestion of the “teacher”.

I have heard that there are cases with some people whose chi energy is so intense that they have trouble controlling their reactions, but not to the extent that I saw in that room that day. To me, it seemed more like mass hysteria.

The “teacher” claimed to be a senior left hand man of the group’s founder Li Hongzhi. His teachings that day consisted of merely telling us to “close [our] eyes and relax… let whatever happens just happen.”

Then after a few minutes of meditation he suggested that we should “begin to feel the chi rising in us, wanting to come out” and if we needed to “jump” or “shout” or “shake,” that was to be expected and to just let go.And that was exactly what people did.

Was it really an intense chi experience or mass hysteria?

My opinion? Mere suggestion can be very powerful, and if people want to believe badly enough, they will do whatever to convince themselves they “have the chi”.

What happens afterwards, whether they come away with any benefit or not is another matter. Perhaps it is enough just to have “faith.” However, based on my experience, I would not consider this real qigong, at least in the sense of systematic training in yogic breathing and meditation.

I only attended one meeting, so I can’t really comment whether the meeting I attended is really representative of what Falun Gong is all about or whether this qigong teaching was a personal interpretation of one disciple.

What I can say is that my perspective is undoubtedly skewed in the sense that I can’t help but compare this encounter with my own personal experiences and training in qigong. Ultimately, I think each person must judge for him- or herself what organizations such as Falun Gong represent.

Perhaps there was more in the qigong that I had yet to experience, but that was the extent of my encounter with Falun Gong, and the events that occurred in that room definitely dissuaded me from continuing.

When people who have never practiced qigong nor ever experienced chi before suddenly develop so much chi that they react spontaneously by jumping up and down, going into spasms or muttering gibberish, I have to ask myself what is going on, and do I really want to be a part of this.

Government-sanctioned qigong? At the time, I could not understand how this Falun Dafa was able to continue with government approval, given China’s anti-religious sentiment and reluctance to associate itself with anything even suggestive of religion.

In fact, I was not very surprised when only several years later in 1999 that the Chinese government began to crack down harshly on the Falun Gong and Zhong Gong, another similar religious group also operating under the guise of qigong.

I don’t think there is anything wrong in joining a “qigong organization” like Falun Gong that makes claims to certain religious beliefs, but I do think its teachers, disciples and any other representative agents should be clear about their intentions.

If you do intend to join such a group, just be aware that practicing qigong is not their primary purpose. Though they may ostensibly offer qigong classes, they may also have other ulterior motives for inviting you to join their group.

text from: http://www.facts.org.cn/puop/201005/t111440.htm